80th Birthday Invitation

My father-in-law is turnng 80 this summer so there's going to be a big party to celebrate. My mother-in-law asked me to design the invitaiton for her. She provided a bunch of photos - old and new. I was leaning towards the older ones - they seem more interesting and have a lot of character. There's something about old photos that I just love! There always seems to be a story behind them. I did 4 versions for her to choose from. They are going to be printed on flat note cards with the party info on the back.

Here are the 4 versions I did:

A:

B:

C:

D:

I wonder which one she'll choose.